Skip to main content

2002 Employment Equality Decisions

Reference Number:Complainant vs Respondent:Key Words:Full Case Report (PDF Document):
DEC-E2002-001
Anne Harrington -v- East Coast Area Health Board 
 View DEC-E2002/001 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-002Mr Gerry Kirwan(Represented by MANDATE) AND Tesco Ireland 
View DEC-E2002/002 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-003Ms. Samantha Black(represented by MANDATE) -v- Tesco Ireland(represented by IBEC)Employment - Discriminatory Treatment - Sex - Access to part-time work - Direct Discrimination
- Indirect Discrimination - whether employer acted reasonably - prima facie case - Employment Equality Act, 1977: sections 2(a), 2(b) and 2(c), section 3, section 13 - Equal Treatment Directive
View DEC-E2002/003 Full Case Report.
DEC-E2002-004AN EMPLOYEE(REPRESENTED BY IMPACT) AND A LOCAL AUTHORITY View DEC-E2002/004 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-005Annette Carroll(Represented by Hegarty & Horgan, Solicitors) -v- Dublin Document Bureau Ltd. (Represented by A & L Goodbody, Solicitors)
 View DEC-E2002/005 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-006Tony Madden(Represented by SIPTU) -v- Aer Lingus (Represented by Tom Mallon, instructed by Arthur Cox Solicitors) View DEC-E2002/006 Full Case Report.
DEC-E2002-007Tony Madden(Represented by the SIPTU) -v- Aer Lingus(Represented by Tom Mallon B.L. instructed by Arthur Cox, Solicitors) View DEC-E2002/007 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-008Sheila Burke(Represented by IMPACT) AND Revenue Commissioners View DEC-E2002/008 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-009A Complainant(Represented by SIPTU) AND A Hospital(Represented by IBEC) 
View DEC-E2002/009 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-010Leon(Represented by Fionnuala Cawkhill & Associates, Solicitors)AND Institute of Public Administration(Represented by IBEC) 
View DEC-E2002/010 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-011Mr. Gerard Fahey V McKinsey & Co. Inc.(Represented by A & L Goodbody, Solicitors)Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Access to employment - Discriminatory
treatment - Age - Jurisdiction - Time Limits - Prima Facie case
View DEC-E2002/011 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-012Mr. Darragh O'Driscoll(Represented by MANDATE) V Tesco Ireland LimitedEmployment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6, 8 and 21 - Employment - Discriminatory treatment - Gender - Terms and conditions of employment - Indirect Discrimination
 View DEC-E2002/012 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-013MS. BARBARA FREEMAN(REPRESENTED BY MANDATE)
AND SUPERQUINN(REPRESENTED BY IBEC)
 
View DEC-E2002/013 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-014A Complainant V A CompanyEmployment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Employment - Discriminatory treatment - Gender - Age - Harassment - Sexual Harassment
View DEC-E2002/014 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-015A Complainant -V - Civil Service Commissioners 
View DEC-E2002/015 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-016A Complainant AND A Department Store(Represented by William Fry, Solicitors) View DEC-E2002/016 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-017A Complainant(Represented by the Equality Authority) AND A Department Store(Represented by William Fry, Solicitors) 
View DEC-E2002/017 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-018Mr Liam O'Mahony, Mr Terence Smith, Mr Michael Lovett, Mr Tomás Ó Tuama(Represented by the Public Service Executive Union)
vs Revenue Commissioners
 
View DEC-E2002/018 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-019Bridget Boland(Represented by O'Mara Geraghty McCourt, Solicitors, on the instructions of the
Equality Authority) AND Eircom
 
View DEC-E2002/019 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-020MS. DYMPNA MINAGUCHI
(REPRESENTED BY O'MARA, GERAGHTY, MCCOURT - SOLICITORS) AND MR. RAY BYRNE, T/A WINEPORT LAKESHORE RESTAURANT
(REPRESENTED BY IBEC)
 
View DEC-E2002/020 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-021Ms. Helen Kelly(Represented by the PSEU) V Department of Social, Community and Family AffairsEmployment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Employment - Discriminatory treatment - Gender - Marital Status - Family Status - Training - Direct Discrimination - Indirect Discrimination
View DEC-E2002/021 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-022Mr. Chrisiakis Sergides V Feehily's Pub(Represented by McGovern Walsh & Co., Solicitors)Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Employment - Discriminatory treatment -Harassment - Victimisation - Race - Prima Facie case - Burden of Proof
View DEC-E2002/022 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-023Susan Curran(Represented by Mandate) AND Newbridge Credit Union(Represented by IBEC) 
View DEC-E2002/023 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-024A Male Employee AND A Government Department
 
View DEC-E2002/024 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-025WILSON(REPRESENTED BY THE EQUALITY AUTHORITY)
AND THE ADELAIDE AND MEATH HOSPITAL (REPRESENTED BY THE HEALTH SERVICES EMPLOYERS AGENCY)
 
View DEC-E2002/025 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-026Brown(Represented by SIPTU)
V Eason & Son Limited(Represented by IBEC)
Employment Equality Act, 1998 Section 19 - Employment - Equal Pay - Prima Facie case - Direct Discrimination - Indirect Discrimination - Grounds other than Gender
View DEC-E2002/026 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-027Marian Walker(Represented by Mandate) -v- Tesco Ireland 
View DEC-E2002/027 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-028Rosaleen Forde(Represented by Mandate) -v- Tesco Ireland 
View DEC-E2002/028 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-029Gay Byrne(Represented by Mandate) -v- Tesco Ireland 
View DEC-E2002/029 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-030Smyth(Represented by SIPTU) AND
University College Dublin(Represented by John J McDonald, Solicitors)
 
View DEC-E2002/030 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-031MURPHY(REPRESENTED BY IMPACT) AND DUBLIN CITY COUNCIL (FORMERLY DUBLIN CORPORATION
(REPRESENTED BY MR. ALEX WHITE BL)
 
View DEC-E2002/031 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-032Rogers(Represented by Mr. Kerr BL
instructed by the Equality Authority)
V Comhfhorbairt Gallimh Teo
t/a Aer Arann (Represented by IBEC)
Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6, 7, 8 and 19 - Employment - Discriminatory
treatment - Gender - Prima Facie case - Equal Pay - Like Work
View DEC-E2002/032 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-033Meaney(Represented by Mr. Kerr B.L. instructed by O'Mara Geraghty McCourt, Solicitors) V
Department of Education and Science
(Represented by Mr. Mallon B.L.
instructed by the Chief State Solicitor's Office)
Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Employment - Discriminatory treatment - Gender - Marital Status - Family Status - Admissibility of Claim - Jurisdiction
View DEC-E2002/033 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-034Tynan(Represented by S.I.P.T.U. )
-v- FAS
 
View DEC-E2002/034 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-035Lynskey(Represented by the Equality Authority) AND The Board of Management of Coolmine Community School(Represented by IBEC) 
View DEC-E2002/035 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-036A Complainant(Represented by Rosemary Connolly, Solicitors)
AND A Company(Represented by IBEC)
 
View DEC-E2002/036 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-037A Complainant AND National Training and Development Institute
(Represented by IBEC)
 
View DEC-E2002/037 Full Case Report 
DEC-E2002-038An Employee V Department of Foreign AffairsEmployment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Employment - Discriminatory treatment - Discriminatory Question - Gender - Marital Status - Family Status - AgeView DEC-E2002/038 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-039Maguire(Represented by the Equality Authority) V North Eastern Health Board(Represented by HSEA)Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6, 8, 15, 32, 56, 74, 77 - Employment - Traveller - Prima Facie case - Burden of Proof - Harassment - Victimisation - DismissalView DEC-E2002/039 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-040O'BYRNE AND THE DEPARTMENT OF PUBLIC ENTERPRISE View DEC-E2002/040 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-041A Complainant(Represented by O'Mara Geraghty McCourt, Solicitors on the instructions of the Equality Authority) AND
A Company(In voluntary liquidation)
 View DEC-E2002/041 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-042An Employee(Represented by Solicitors) -v- An Employer(Represented by Solicitors) View DEC-E2002/042 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-043Francis(Represented by MANDATE) V Dunnes Stores Castlebar(Represented by William Fry Solicitors)Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 7 and 19 - Employment - Equal Pay - Like Work - Prima Facie case - Grounds other than GenderView DEC-E2002/043 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-044(1) An Employee vs Midland Health Board (2) 254 Employees vs South Eastern Health Board (3) 189 Employees vs Midland Health Board
Claimants' Representative : INO
Employers' Representative : HSEA
 View DEC-E2002/044 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-045Byrne AND FÁS(Represented by William Fry, Solicitors) View DEC-E2002/045 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-046McCormick(Represented by the Equality Authority) AND Dublin Port Company(Represented by Arthur Cox, Solicitors) View DEC-E2002/046 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-047Sheehan(Represented by Cornelius Sheehan & Co, Solicitors) AND
Director of Public Prosecutions
(Represented by Arthur Cox, Solicitors)
 View DEC-E2002/047 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-048McNamee(Represented by IMPACT) V Donegal County CouncilEmployment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Employment - Promotion - GenderView DEC-E2002/048 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-049Hughes(Represented by the Equality Authority) AND Aer Lingus (Represented by Arthur Cox, Solicitors) View DEC-E2002/049 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-050Margetts(Represented by Mandate)
AND Graham Anthony & Co, Ltd
(Represented by Denis McSweeney, Solicitors)
 View DEC-E2002/050 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-051ROBERTS(REPRESENTED BY IMPACT) AND DUNLAOGHAIRE/RATHDOWN COUNTY COUNCIL View DEC-E2002/051 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-052Fernandez -v- Cable & Wireless
(Represented by I.B.E.C. )
 View DEC-E2002/052 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-053Harrington -v- Cable & Wireless
(Represented by I.B.E.C. )
 View DEC-E2002/053 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-054McGinn(Represented by the INO)
V Daughters of Charity of St. Vincent de Paul(Represented by IBEC)
Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 6 and 8 - Employment - Discriminatory treatment - Gender - Promotion - VictimisationView DEC-E2002/054 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-05510 Named Employees(Represented by SIPTU) V Limerick City Council
(Represented by Local Government
Management Services Board)
Employment Equality Act, 1998 Sections 7 and 19 - Employment - Equal Pay - Public HolidaysView DEC-E2002/055 Full Case Report
DEC-E2002-056An Employee V A Government Department(Represented by Mr. Anthony Kerr BL instructed by the Chief State Solicitor) View DEC-E2002/056 Full Case Report